Lafayette College President Nicole Hurd signed onto a letter released Tuesday condemning “unprecedented government overreach and political interference” in American higher education by the Trump administration. The letter, signed by more than 250 college presidents and higher education leaders, comes after Harvard University — the president of which is also a signatory — refused to comply with a list of demands from the federal government.
“This call for constructive engagement aligns with Lafayette College’s mission and values,” an email sent by college spokesman Scott Morse on Hurd’s behalf read.
“Lafayette, at its core—past and present—stands on the principles articulated in the statement, in particular the importance of not ‘abridging the defining freedoms of American higher education,’” the email continues.
Morse previously did not rule out complying with the Trump administration if the college were to be threatened by it.
In the letter — published by the American Association of Colleges and Universities, of which Lafayette is a member — the signatories reject “the coercive use of public research funding” and “undue government intrusion,” though they add that they are “open to constructive reform and do not oppose legitimate government oversight.”
Hurd deferred comment to Morse on what such reform and oversight would look like at Lafayette. Morse wrote in an email that “it would be premature and inappropriate to speculate without knowing what is possible through constructive engagement.”
A spokesman for the American Association of Colleges and Universities pointed to a news release that also did not address what would be accepted reform and oversight.
Signatories of the Tuesday letter represent a broad range of American undergraduate institutions, including substantial representation from the country’s small liberal arts colleges. Similar selective liberal arts colleges in the Northeast, such as Bates College, Haverford College, Amherst College and Williams College, signed onto the letter.
Earlier this month, 82 past and present college presidents, including two former Lafayette presidents, signed onto a separate letter published in Fortune Magazine decrying the Trump administration’s actions in higher education and backing Harvard’s resistance. Hurd was not approached about this letter, according to the email sent by Morse on her behalf.
Former Lafayette College president Alison Byerly, the current president of Carleton College, was one of just eight current presidents to sign the letter. She also signed the American Association of Colleges and Universities letter.
“One of the challenges of the current moment for higher education is that it is difficult to know how to push back against vague threats on many different fronts,” Byerly wrote in an email. “Until there is a specific action to protest, it’s hard to know where to start.”
“There is no question that many people felt heartened by seeing Harvard offer such a strong response to the very specific and alarming demands they received from the federal government,” she added.
Former Lafayette College president Daniel Weiss, who served before Byerly, said he signed the letter because he felt “very strongly that we need to speak out about what we think is right.”
“That means something,” he said. “To hear from such a large number of people who have led institutions, that we know something about what’s at stake.”
William Neil • Apr 27, 2025 at 7:48 am
Thank you very much for covering this. I got “here” this morning, Sunday, April 27, 2025 after reading (in the NY Times) about the 400 colleges and universities who issued a four paragraph “push back” against the Trump administration’s heavy hand against schools who don’t align with it culturally – or politically. I have to add the political because the two are being blended together.
I scrolled down the unnumbered list which the Times’ article linked to, and it took a while, but there was Lafayette in the company of Princeton, Amherst, F & M, Bucknell, Muhlenberg…Oberlin, and, I am pleased to report, the American Studies Association (my major at Lafayette) and the American Historical Association.
I think the article is perhaps too restrained, although the content is tougher than that awful title of “A Call for Constructive Engagement.”!
That sounds like a note left at the breakfast table after a nasty domestic spat the night before – (advised by Tony Soprano’s therapist?)
I think – and thank you for doing the digging on this – that the two former Lafayette Presidents got the tone right – a tougher one to meet the call of the moment, if not the gauntlet that Trump has thrown down not just to colleges, but the very essence of democracy as we have known it in the old U.S. republic…often in need of major repairs and innovations, but never threatened like this since the late 1850’s.
I hope we end better than in 1860.
William R. Neil, Class of 1972